Friday, January 22, 2010

An Onion by any other name, well it's not the smell that matters (for my purposes)

So I have made it past another funk (thanks, Heather Kelly, for getting me working) and I think I can write again. I was feeling a little messy for a few days, like my fingers couldn't even move. One of the things I love about writing is the epiphanies. They don't happen nearly often enough. The moments when everything seems so clear, when this writing is like you're god making the onion one layer at a time.

So I think the epiphany began with Fire and thinking about characters making entrances. It continued with Mr. Dahl, and thinking about POV and narration.  And finally was pulled all together with Jesse Lee Kercheval and her book, Building Fiction. I love all writing books and hers is one I've turned to over and over again. I've read these chapters more than once, but the wiser I am about writing, the more I get out of her examples. I read the whole chapter "Continuing Conflict," but the section on "Internal Conflict Development" was exactly what I needed.

When I was in grad school, and before that really, I learned the show, don't tell rule and I learned it hard. Internal character thoughts felt like telling (so, you know, instead of being confused they scratched their head) but a first person narrator talks about thinking. Does it not?? But learning how to do this effectively has been like pulling out my teeth. It should be kind of elementary(my dear Watson) when I look at it now. 

But if I think of the story in terms of the onion, or, wait, do I think of myself like an onion? Because maybe I can't see that part of the story, until part of me is peeled away? I'm not sure of the onion metaphor, But, finally, my characters' thoughts are part of the conversation, where the conflict speaks and my MC responds with something that, like good dialog, furthers the tension. Or at least she will soon.

Can you tell that I'm learning to pull everything apart? That's why first it was the entrances with Fire and then that breaking down the smart little narrator for FMF and now this, the thoughts. So the story is the onion, but I am too.

As Always (working it out),
Tina

15 comments:

  1. Tina--You're welcome. (although I'm pretty sure you helped me more than I helped you...) I love this post--and I think I need to read BUILDING FICTION. Building and maintaining conflict seems to be the theme of the week. I'm so happy you are on a roll...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, I for one love onions.

    Let me know when you get it all figured out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm going to go with a head of iceberg lettuce, but I like your point.

    (onions and are enemies in so many ways)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Heather--gosh, I think our wrap around plan (deadline, production, conflict) that could eventually benefit the world. it's nice to be in it together.

    Anita- I love onions too, smelly layers and all. And I'll keep you posted. But I probably will need you to teach me a thing or two.

    Jonathon- Onions just want to be your friend. I spose iceberg works, but I really thought you were more exciting than that.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh, really, they wanna be my friend... Why is it that they make me cry more than anything I've ever known? They give me awful headaches and they taste gross. We are sworn enemies, there's no going back.

    I am an exciting person, yes, but I L-O-V-E lettuce. I frequently eat whole heads of lettuce and proceed to pee for two straight hours. So, at first I thought I'd concede and find something else to fit within your metaphor, but I'm stickin' with lettuce, dammit. We can go romaine if you're going to be picky.

    ReplyDelete
  6. You are EXCITING! That is right. And a lettuce lover. I think I'll stick with iceberg because the layers are hard to peel apart. You are iceberg lettuce, my friend. And so is your novel?

    ReplyDelete
  7. You guys are making me hungry ... I'm suddenly craving a wedge of iceberg w/ ranch and some grilled onions on a beef dip hogie. mmmm...

    seriously, though. I have (so many times)shared your thoughts, Tina. Thanks for posting them.

    here's a mantra to share: We can do this. It may be difficult, but we will push through and peel back those layers and make it beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Tess, Mmmm. You're making me hungry! Probably if I made my prose beautiful, I'd eat it. Thanks for the mantra. And the encouragement!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. My novel Tina, at the moment, is definitely hard to peel apart. It is frustrating and fun at the same time. I frequently struggle to grasp those cold layer of lettuce, but once I get them peeled back and cleaned, there's yummy goodness inside.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Mmm, lettuce. Crispy and green, just like spring. I may be a convert. But my novel makes me cry. And it might make me smell, because sometimes poeple don't like being around me. More like an onion. Go figure.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is making me hungry!lol.
    stopped by your blog. Great stuff!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Internal thoughts are very hard to get right, but without them, a story can flop. And the thoughts that are telling are the worst - so I don't blame you for steering away from them. Internal thoughts really don't get the attention they deserve on blogs and how to do them right. Looking forward to your interview on Friday with Heather! - Laura

    ReplyDelete
  13. Well, I strongly dislike onions. But in relation to writing, they're pure genius. See, you only have to work on one layer at a time. And it stinks. And it's long. But it's worth it in the end. Glad you got over your funk!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Welcome, Terry Lynn Johnson!

    Thanks, Laura! It's good to hear they are not just hard for me. I sometimes feel like I'm the only one who doesn't get it! Although I guess I'm okay with being a little backwards. Thanks for coming over!

    Elana, Onions seem to be controversial!! But I agree about the work of it. And the one layer at a time comment is what is genius! I forget that all the time and need to be reminded. Perhaps after this post that thought will be cemented! (Not likely, unfortunately I'm a slow learner.)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks for the thoughts on thoughts. I'm glad you are writing again. I'm in the middle of figuring out how to convey my MCs thoughts in an intense scene.

    ReplyDelete