Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Finished Shiver by Maggie Stiefvater
This book gets better as you go. I finished it on Sunday and ever since I can't help stopping at the kitchen window to check out the line of pines that border our yard. I’m looking for ghostly figures out there, piercing eyes, a cloud of breath. Maybe it's all the more evocative to read Stiefvaters book during a Minnesota winter. For me the cold, the snow, wolf eyes, the white pages with the blue font(so beautiful!), all of it worked together and the images have been haunting me for the last couple of days. In Stephanie Meyer’s books (you know the ones), you smell vampires and wolves all over the place but I couldn’t help think that Meyer’s vampires smelled like over-ripe canalope and her wolves like wet-dog (I’ve said this before, sorry if I get boring), but Maggie Stiefvater made me want to go put my face in my dog’s ruff(his name is Haimish) and I usually avoid that kind of thing.
Romance, Stiefvater does that well. And Sam is so likable, both in boy and wolf forms. I also liked him in first person or from Grace’s perspective. I returned the book to the library because there were folks waiting on it, or I would look a little more closely at how she used the changing perspectives to build tension in the story. It seems to me you would need to slide into the perspective of the character who has the most to lose. But knowing me I would avoid that character!
As Always (best laid plans: I WAS going to post my plot mapping--maybe tomorrow--and a response to Paul Greci's reading post--I loved it!--and I want to do a post on some reading my son is doing--Steve B. that's about you--later in this week, oh and AWARDS, so behind),
Tina
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Hi Tina, I haven't read Shiver so I don't have much to say except your non-spoiler thoughts have put it back on my radar. I usually don't read any reviews of books I know I am going to read but Shiver was on my maybe list b/c I gravitate toward realistic fiction. Thanks for your thoughts. It sounds like a book I might enjoy.
ReplyDeletePaul- I really loved the feel of the book and it has totally stuck with me. And seriously I have felt several times since that I didn't actually finish the book. It is still sort of haunting me on a sort of visceral level. I'm curious what you will think. Let me know.
ReplyDeleteI am about a third of the way through Shiver right now. I do like it so far. And I put my face in the ruff of my pup's fur on a daily basis. I really do. She's so soft and cute!
ReplyDeleteI'll let you know what I think of it all when I'm done!
My dog is big and smelly at this point in his life. But he is pretty, if a little crotchety. I can't wait to hear what you think.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed Shiver. I think Maggie's writing style is beautifully lyrical. Almost like reading a novel-length poem. And she's got teen angst down pat!
ReplyDeleteOMG! My word verification is wooff!
I read and liked LAMENT very much, but for some reason I'm hesitating on SHIVER. Thanks for your thoughts--I may be edging closer reading it.
ReplyDeleteI've also thought about reading SHIVER, but I keep skipping it over because I can't shake this prejudice that it's a more were-wolfey TWILIGHT romance thing.
ReplyDeleteHated TWILIGHT. Passionately.
But if you tell me SHIVER is nothing like that, I might give it a try.
I've heard of this .. seen it around .. but haven't yet read it. Maybe I will have to pick it up...
ReplyDeleteMg's comment is funny to me. I totally gobbled SHIVER up, and have had Sam lust ever since, but I am totally hesitant to go into a Stiefvater fairy world or whatever it's about.
ReplyDeleteMy word ver is phague. Will you call me that Tina, can that be my nickname?
Hi, Anissa! I love the word ver! So perfect! Okay, how does that work really? It must be rigged.
ReplyDeleteMG- I also liked Lament but was not so into Ballad. I really liked Shiver I got to say. And I would just check it out for the font color. It really is a beautiful book.
Ray- Well, Ray, I got to say it is a wolfy romance thing but it is not Twilight. For me a lot more pleasant. But I did sort of like the initial Twilight romance. Just to be totally honest with you. And sometimes I'm an easy read.
Tess- It is very different from When You Reach Me! And that book is Fab.
J- Yes, Sam is hot. He had the perfect amount of vulnerability I'd say. And so mellow. He may be perfect for you. Don't go to Stiefvater fairy world. Her wolf world is much better.
And I think you misheard the word ver. It sounds more like vague. I think it was the computer fairy's critique of my review. Don't worry I have plenty of nicknames for you!
So not like Twilight it knocked my socks off!
ReplyDeleteOkay. I did really like Shiver. The writing was excellent, poetic, strong word choice...and all of that.
ReplyDeleteBut I did think it was a bit like Twilight, just better written. And even, though I loved reading it, there were parts that were a bit creepy and unrealistic(even though she made them believable). And, I'll stop there.
Update your read list. I've never told you, but I love the colors on your blog.
ReplyDeleteJ- So did Laura answer you on that one! Not like Twilight because of the better writing!
ReplyDeleteLaura- Thanks! I love you telling it like it is. I agree. And yet I'm all about the good read these days. And it really has haunted me. Not in a creepy way either. In a I want a big dog watching me from the woods kind of way (and as I write that it sounds like Twilight to me but somehow Stiefvater made it bright and beautiful instead of the dirty feel I had w/ twilight). Is that the good writing?
Thanks, J! A Carl Larsson inspired palate. You should see my house. On to the read list!
ReplyDeleteI'm not trying to be troublesome, but I didn't get TWILIGHT vibes whatsoever. Stiefvater's writing felt clean and crisp and her own. Plus, there wasn't the whole love triangle going on. I definitely see the points behind the comparisons, but I believe it goes way beyond a higher skill set regarding writing.
ReplyDeleteI can't wait to read this one. I wish the list at the library were shorter. Maybe I'll just go buy it... :)
ReplyDeleteBoy am I late to the party. I liked Shiver, but I didn't love it. I think I read it right between Graceling, Fire and Hunger Games. And, it just seemed like a littler book. Maybe I need to read it again. I did like it! I never did the Twilight thing. But I thought Shiver was well written. I just wanted it to be... more, I guess. Sorry to dampen the love fest, and I'd be disappointed if both Tina and Jon didn't respond...
ReplyDeleteJ- It totally has Twilight vibes. Werewolves and not able to be together. But Steifvater's writing is all her own. And Grace and Bella are so different. And Sam. Hot. Although lots of folk like Edward just fine and Jacob for that matter. But Steifvater didn't make anyone sparkle and the werewolves are just regular sized and a hell of a lot cooler. And haunting me.
ReplyDeleteElana- I had to wait such a long time! But the book IS so pretty. Nice one to own. Thank you for coming by!
HK- Never late, just fashionable. And those books you read it between has such other worldly worlds. Shiver was just here in the chills of little old MN. And current day. I could see how it would not stand up to the comparison. Well, or at least seem smaller. And I think the parts that I'm so attached to with it are the things that are so here and everyday. Like, I can picture the wolves, so dog-like, and the cold, breath clouding the air.
Oh, man, sorry everybody, I just keep going...
Reasons TWILIGHT and SHIVER are so different:
ReplyDelete1. Maggie never treated Werewolf-ism as a 'cool' thing, something to aspire to. It has always been a curse for Sam.
2. The human experience is almost completely removed from the wolves in Mercy Falls. LaPush's wolves were very well aware of what they are, were, and what they can do, from a human stand point. Sam, and counterparts, are always confined to either being a wolf or a human...never both.
3. I'd argue that SHIVER has the perfect balance between plot-driven and character-driven storyline. TWILIGHT was much heavier on plot.
4. Grace is fascinated with who Sam is. Bella is fascinated with what Edward is.
5. Sam and Grace are attempting a normal life. Bella and Edward want out of the normal, they want it to be just them and no one else.
Now I am just talking outta my ass. Enjoy.
Crap, Grace and Sam want a cure.
ReplyDeleteBella only thinks about becoming a vamp.
J- I'm torn between sticking up my dukes or waving my white flag. Good thing this is virtual fighting. (Totally fun, btw)
ReplyDeleteKelly, you must be almost done. What do you think?
I prefer the former!
ReplyDeleteI know a lot of our blog buds liked SHIVER, but it just did not work for me. Can't put a finger on why.
ReplyDelete..."Shiver" must have it's share of followers none-the-less. I've been on a 2 month waiting list at the local library to get my hands on it. One hopes by the time my number is finally called, they'll still be a page or two not falling out of the binding.
ReplyDeleteElliot - Maybe the copy you'll end up with will have been checked out by the book-hoarders, those that let it sit on their nightstand and then realize it's due in two days, so they just return it.
ReplyDeleteThen again, maybe you'll end up with a copy that twelve teens had. It comes complete with snacks and everything!
Tina - I like vague reviews, they make mine look more normal.
ReplyDeleteAnita- So did you like Twilight???
ReplyDeleteEliot- I know I had to wait that long myself. Longer. And then I did hoard it and didn't read until I had two days left. Sucked in none the less.
J- I read by feeling my way through. I must review that way as well. And I provide normal making service. Nice of me, huh?!
Shiver is on my to read list. Maybe I should move it up a little higher. Thanks for the review.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, I gave you an award on my blog http://misadventuresinspelling.blogspot.com/2010/03/i-officially-rock.html
It is a service! And you always tell me I'm doing you a service.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Kate! I'll head over.
ReplyDeleteWolves bum me out. I was paying attention & learned what I was supposed to from Red Riding Hood & those little pigs. BUT... all this talk about Shiver... there's something there... I'll read it. Yikes.
ReplyDeleteRobert, you'll read it and you'll like it. That's not an order, just a hunch. And why do wolves bum you out?! I love them...we only have minibears and coyotes here. Nothing exciting, like sexy werefolk.
ReplyDeleteRobert- The book may bring you round to the wolf point of view.
ReplyDeleteJ- You may be the sexy werefolk. You have yet to prove otherwise.
I like vague reviews because it doesn't give too much away.
ReplyDeleteI finished it!
I thought it had Twilight vibes with him being secretly in the bedroom and the werewolf thing, but loved Grace. Bella was too obsessed and Edward too controlling. Sam and Grace were more normal despite their abnormalities. Also, I am so not a romantic person, but I did enjoy the romance in here. Very well done and made me a little wistful thinking about how it is when you first fall in love with someone. There's nothing quite like it!
I agree with a lot of what Kelly says.
ReplyDeleteKelly- Thanks so much for reporting in(and liking vague revues because I sure love to write them!). I knew if anyone could satisfy the Shiver police, you could. I personally think J may have some kind of insider knowledge, so he probably does know best.
ReplyDeleteJ- Thanks for making me wise, like you.
okay, this post was quite good - but the comments are VERY entertaining! What a conversation going on here!
ReplyDeleteIf I may jump in here, I sort of agree with Heather. I also read it right after Hunger Games and before Graceling! And I also felt it was an okay book. Perhaps I'd read too much hype about it before I read it. But, it was a little bit like Twilight, sorry Jon, but that's not a bad thing. I liked Twilight!
Yay, TerryLynn, for jumping in! It is so interesting between those very big books. I can't get over how different would be. I also am not a Twilight hater. I certainly read it faster than Shiver. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI'm on the waiting list for "Shiver" in the library!
ReplyDeleteSo looking forward to reading it!
Dena- when you are done will you leave a comment here and compare it to Twilight? Thanks for coming by!
ReplyDeleteI'm in the middle of Shiver right now. I have to say that I love love love Sam. Maggie S. referred to him somewhere as an "innocent bambi" - I love the innocent teenage boy. I'm trying to write that type of character now (he's not a wolf, or a vampire for that matter) and it's neat to see how she does it.
ReplyDeleteKris--I love that, "innocent bambi" he is really appealing and that is a good description. Thanks for coming by.
ReplyDelete